Tuesday, March 10 @ 11:37 AM
Watchmen by Alan MooreMy review
rating: 4 of 5 stars
This book may have received a 5-star rating if not for the ending.
I do not normally read comic books, graphic novels, or other similar publications. It's not that I don't like them. I just prefer reading regular novels and nonfiction. When I do occasionally read one, I am reminded of just how good they can be. This was the case with Watchmen.
This graphic novel reads like a novel at times. The darkness of the storyline and the raw nature of some of the characters makes it feel like the author really committed to finding the deeper parts of his characters.
The setting is also intriguing: United States, 1985. It is the height of the Cold War. The story revolves around this setting as well, keeping you on the edge of your seat as to what will happen next in this international game of brinkmanship with the Soviet Union.
Even though there is some blood, violence, and grotesque thoughts in this story, I appreciated those things for being so real. I normally do not like those aspects of comic books or graphic novels. I don't like seeing people get their head blown off or an animal get killed. The panels with things like that in them make me feel ill. However, Watchmen pulled that off ok. It's still hard to look at sometimes, but it fits into the darkness of the story.
There are a couple of characters that really steal the show: Rorschach and Nite Owl II were fantastic. Especially Rorschach. He's the most violent and has a bit of an absolutist mindset when it comes to his worldview. He never compromises. Normally I would not like a character like that, but he's just so damn intriguing.
However, the one big disappointment in this story was the ending. Don't worry, I'm not going to give anything away. While reading the book I thought the ending would really be something. I thought Moore would really blow us away with a deep idea or an incredible fight or a sad, dark reality (in the spirit of the book!) However, the ending seemed dull, weird, and completely out of left field. The idea he plants in this ending is an interesting one, but it just didn't feel right to me. It ended more with a whimper than anything else.
Anyway, a fun read and, once again, an enjoyable journey down the path of non-traditional reading.
View all my reviews.




















